If you only make one Thanksgiving cocktail, make a big batch that guests can pour themselves, like a pear and ginger sangria or a slow cooker of mulled wine. Add one shaken drink for arrivals, such as an apple cider margarita or cranberry mule, and give every drink a non-alcoholic version.
Slightly bossy opinion: the host should not be the bartender on Thanksgiving. You already have a turkey, six sides and a relative asking when dinner is, and shaking cocktails one at a time on top of that is how the gravy burns. So my favorite Thanksgiving cocktail ideas look special and then mostly look after themselves.
These ten drinks are sorted by when you’d actually serve them, from something bright and cold when people walk in, to lighter drinks that don’t fight the food, to warm and sweet ones that go with pie. Each has simple measurements for one glass, the batch-friendly ones are flagged, and every drink has an easy swap for anyone skipping alcohol.

Recommended blogs to read:
- Thanksgiving appetizer ideas
- Thanksgiving charcuterie board ideas
- Thanksgiving party decor
- holiday and party decor ideas
Start by picking two drinks: one batch drink you can make the day before, and one cocktail you’ll shake for people as they arrive. Buy the mixers, juices and garnishes a few days early, and make any syrups on Wednesday, so Thursday is just pouring.
What Are the Most Popular Thanksgiving Cocktails?
Apple cider margaritas, cranberry Moscow mules, pumpkin spice martinis and maple bourbon old fashioneds are some of the most popular Thanksgiving cocktails. They use flavors people already connect with fall, and none of them needs a fancy bar.
Spiced Apple Cider Margarita

A spiced apple cider margarita is the best arrival drink of the lot, because it’s cold, bright and lighter than most fall cocktails. The glass in this photo has a cinnamon sugar rim, plenty of ice, a sprig of rosemary and a whole cinnamon stick, and that rim is what makes people say oh before they’ve had a sip.
Shake 1.5 oz tequila, 2 oz apple cider, 3/4 oz fresh lime juice and 1/2 oz orange liqueur with ice and strain over fresh ice. For a pitcher, multiply by eight, keep it in the fridge and put the ice in the glasses instead of the jug so it doesn’t water down. Skip the tequila and top cider and lime with soda water for the mocktail.
Pumpkin Spice Martini

A pumpkin spice martini is dessert in a glass, so serve it with or after the pie. This one sits in a coupe with a thick, creamy foam on top, a dusting of spice and three coffee beans, with white mini pumpkins on the table behind it.
Shake 1.5 oz vanilla vodka, 1 oz pumpkin puree, 1 oz coffee liqueur and 1 oz cream very hard with ice, then double-strain so the puree doesn’t make it gritty. Grate a little nutmeg over the top. For a no-alcohol version, blend pumpkin puree, milk, a spoon of maple syrup and pumpkin spice with ice.
Cranberry Moscow Mule

Make the cranberry Moscow mule if you want the crowd-pleaser, because it’s built right in the mug, so there’s no shaking at all. That hammered copper mug is full of ice, fresh cranberries, a lime wedge and a sprig of rosemary, which is about as Thanksgiving as a drink gets.
Fill the mug with ice, add 1.5 oz vodka, 2 oz cranberry juice and 1/2 oz lime juice, then top with ginger beer. Drop the vodka and add more ginger beer for an easy mocktail that looks exactly the same, so nobody feels left out.
Maple Bourbon Old Fashioned

A maple bourbon old fashioned is the one for whiskey fans, and maple makes a classic taste like November. The glass here is short and heavy, poured over one big ice cube, with a curl of orange peel and a dark cocktail cherry sitting on top.
Stir 2 oz bourbon, 1 to 2 teaspoons maple syrup and two dashes of Angostura bitters with ice for about 20 seconds, then strain over a large cube and twist an orange peel over the glass. An old fashioned doesn’t batch well and doesn’t have a great mocktail twin, so make it to order for the two or three people who’ll ask.
Which Thanksgiving Drinks Work Warm or in a Big Batch?
Hot buttered rum and sangria are the two easiest to prep ahead, because the butter mix and the wine base can both sit in the fridge overnight. Make them the day before and you only have to add hot water or bubbles.
Hot Buttered Rum

Hot buttered rum is the cozy, warm drink for later in the evening, and the hard part is done days ahead. This glass mug has a foamy golden top and sits on a wooden board with cinnamon sticks, a block of butter and whole nutmeg around it.
Mash softened butter with brown sugar, cinnamon and a pinch of nutmeg and keep it in the fridge. To serve, drop a heaped tablespoon into a mug, add 1.5 oz dark rum and top with hot water, then stir until it melts. Use hot apple cider instead of rum and water for the alcohol-free version.
Pear and Ginger Sangria

Pear and ginger sangria is the big-batch drink I’d make if I could only make one, because it’s light, it chills overnight and guests pour it themselves. The pale sangria here is being poured into glass jar mugs, with white and pink flowers on a teal cloth beside them.
Mix a bottle of dry white wine, 1 cup pear juice, 2 oz brandy, a sliced pear and a few thin slices of fresh ginger in a pitcher and chill for at least four hours. Add soda water just before serving so it stays fizzy. For the mocktail, swap the wine and brandy for white grape juice and sparkling water.
Which Cocktails Go With Thanksgiving Dinner and Dessert?
Tart, fizzy or warm-spiced drinks go best with the meal and afterward, because they cut through rich food and wake up a tired palate. Save the creamy and caramel drinks for dessert.
Cinnamon-Spiced Whiskey Sour

A cinnamon whiskey sour cuts through a rich dinner better than most cocktails, because it’s tart before it’s sweet. These two are served over ice in dimpled glasses on a gold tray, with halved lemons and oranges and a cinnamon stick scattered around them.
Shake 2 oz whiskey, 3/4 oz fresh lemon juice and 1/2 oz cinnamon syrup with ice and strain over fresh ice. Cinnamon syrup is just equal parts sugar and water simmered with two cinnamon sticks, and it keeps in the fridge for about two weeks. Egg white is optional, so skip it if you’re serving a crowd.
Mulled Wine Infused with Cloves and Orange

Mulled wine is the easiest warm drink for a crowd, and it makes the whole house smell like the holidays. Here two glass mugs sit on a round gray tray, each with an orange slice and a star anise floating on top, and a spare cinnamon stick and star anise on the side.
Warm a bottle of red wine with a sliced orange, a few cloves, two cinnamon sticks, a star anise and 2 to 3 tablespoons of honey, and never let it boil. Then keep it on warm in a slow cooker with a ladle. In Finland we drink glögi from November right through Christmas, so a pot of this always feels like the season has started. Mulled apple cider is the non-alcoholic twin.
Pomegranate Gin Fizz

Need something pretty for the table that won’t knock anyone out before the turkey? A pomegranate gin fizz looks the most festive of the lot and is light enough to sip with dinner. Bright pink fills the cut crystal glass, with ice, a pale slice of fruit, a rosemary sprig and pomegranate seeds scattered at the base. For one glass, shake 1.5 oz gin, 1 oz pomegranate juice and 1/2 oz lemon juice with ice, strain into an ice-filled glass and top with soda water. Pomegranate juice and soda with a squeeze of lemon is a pretty good mocktail on its own.
Caramel Apple Mule

A caramel apple mule is the dessert-time drink for people who’d rather not have a creamy martini. The copper mug pictured is topped with a big swirl of whipped cream and a cinnamon stick, on a wooden board with red apples beside it.
Fill a mug with ice, add 1.5 oz vodka or bourbon, 2 oz apple cider and about 1/2 oz caramel sauce, top with ginger beer and finish with whipped cream. Want it a little less sweet? Leave off the whipped cream and add a squeeze of lime. It pairs very well with the pies in my Thanksgiving dessert ideas post.
What Do People Typically Drink on Thanksgiving?
Wine is the classic drink with Thanksgiving dinner, usually a light red like Pinot Noir or a crisp white, along with beer, apple cider and sparkling drinks. Cocktails tend to show up before dinner and with dessert rather than during the meal.
That’s why it makes sense to plan cocktails around arrivals and dessert and let wine and water carry the meal itself. If you serve snacks with the arrival drinks, my Thanksgiving appetizer ideas post has easy pairings.
How Do You Set Up a Self-Serve Thanksgiving Drink Station?
Set up the drink station away from the kitchen, with one batch drink in a dispenser or pitcher, a bucket of ice, glasses, garnishes and a big jug of water. A small card naming each drink and its no-alcohol version saves you answering the same question twenty times.
Put the alcohol-free options right next to the cocktails, not hidden in the fridge, so drivers and kids have something that looks just as nice. Keep plenty of water out and make sure everyone has a safe way home. A tray, a few candles and a little greenery make it look like part of the party, and my Thanksgiving party decor post has more ideas for that corner.
Which Thanksgiving Cocktail Should You Make?
If you’re making only one or two drinks, use this quick guide to pick the ones that fit your evening.
| Cocktail | Best for | Batch friendly? | Easy mocktail swap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Apple cider margarita | Before dinner | Yes | Cider, lime and soda |
| Cranberry mule | Crowds | Yes | Extra ginger beer |
| Maple bourbon old fashioned | Whiskey fans | No | Not recommended |
| Pear and ginger sangria | Big groups | Yes | White grape juice |
| Mulled wine | After dinner | Yes | Mulled cider |
| Pumpkin spice martini | Dessert | No | Pumpkin milkshake |
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s a good drink to have with Thanksgiving dinner?
A light red wine like Pinot Noir, a crisp white wine or a tart, fizzy cocktail like a cranberry mule or pomegranate gin fizz goes well with Thanksgiving dinner. Light, acidic drinks cut through rich food better than sweet or creamy ones.
What is the best big-batch Thanksgiving drink?
Sangria and mulled wine are the best big-batch Thanksgiving drinks, because both can be made ahead and served from a pitcher or slow cooker. Guests serve themselves and you stay out of the bar.
How do I make a Thanksgiving mocktail?
Mix apple cider or cranberry juice with ginger beer or sparkling water, add a squeeze of lime or lemon and a fall garnish like rosemary or a cinnamon stick. Serve it in the same glass as the cocktail so it looks just as special.
How far ahead can I make Thanksgiving cocktails?
Sangria and syrups can be made a day ahead, and hot buttered rum mix keeps in the fridge for several days. Add ice, soda water, ginger beer or sparkling wine only right before serving so the drinks stay fizzy.
What are some popular cocktails for November?
Popular November cocktails include apple cider margaritas, cranberry mules, maple old fashioneds, hot buttered rum and mulled wine. They lean on fall flavors like apple, cranberry, maple and warm spices.
Key Takeaways
- Make one batch drink so you are not stuck at the bar.
- Shake a single bright cocktail for arrivals.
- Keep dinner drinks light and tart, save creamy ones for pie.
- Every drink can have a no-alcohol twin that looks the same.
- Prep syrups and the sangria the day before.
- Add bubbles and ice at the last minute.
Pour the Sangria, Then Go Plan the Snacks
Once the batch drink is chilling in the fridge and the margarita mix is ready, the bar mostly runs itself, and you get to be a host who actually sits down. Drinks taste better with something to nibble on, so the natural next step is the food that goes next to them, and my Thanksgiving charcuterie board ideas post is where I’d go from here, cocktail in hand.
